Buffalo Dining Club, Darlinghurst

on Nov 9, 2014 in European, Italian, Other

Buffalo Dining Club, Darlinghurst

Just last week we had a little get together to catch up with some fellow bloggers, Sherrie (Crystal Noir) suggested Buffalo Dining Club because simply put ‘CHEESE WHEEL’ and thus the decision was made. We were also joined by Matt & Beryl (PlanMB), Elena (Ellie’s Belly Adventures) and also bumped into Mel (The Adventures of Miss Piggy) while we were there.

Buffalo mozzarella w/ chilli broccolini and cherry tomatoes

Groups larger than four are required to have the house order food for them, they ask if anyone has any allergies or preferences and then the party starts. I’ve always been a fan of buffalo mozarella so I was happy to see this one land on the table as part of the first wave of food. The cheese tasted really fresh and light, the cherry tomatoes and broccolini which Miss K devoured were also really nice.

Caprino w/ grilled artichoke hearts and honey baby carrots

The creamy caprino was probably my favourite cheese of the night, both of us have always been fans of goats cheese and this one was the most flavoursome of the three, it tasted really good when spread over the bread. The carrots and artichokes were nice but not overly amazing.

Burrata w/ marinated olives and tempura cauliflower

The burrata cheese was the first I’ve had and I really liked it, the oddly stringy texture was actually nice and the cheese itself was a little bit salty. The table didn’t seem to be big fans of the olives but the tempura cauliflowers were the winning side for me since they were so crispy.

Pumpkin and potato croquettes, beetroot sauce

Along with the cheese plates they also provided two extra sides of croquettes and tangy beetroot sauce, these tasted really crispy but as with any other fried goods it’s difficult to compare freshness of ingredients which I think is the draw factor here at Buffalo Dining Club.

Wagyu bresaola and rocket

San Daniele Prosciutto

To accompany the cheese plates there are also a variety of cured meats on the menu, the wagyu bresaola drowning in olive oil was a clear winner simply because it tasted nothing short of amazing while the prosciutto was also really nice and soft.

Gnocchi – buffalo ricotta gnocchi with a napolitana sauce

Ragu – slow cooked lamb shoulder ragu with orecchiette pasta

The Gnocchi and Ragu came out as part of the second wave of food, both pastas were really good but the gnocchi seemed to be most popular. I generally don’t enjoy gnocchi because they’re too dense but these were made just right and almost melt in your mouth, it also went well with the REALLY spicy chilli sauce.

Pecorino Cheese Wheel

Cacio e Pepe – pasta, salt, pepper, olive oil and parsley

Everyone was quite excited to see the famous pasta prepared in a cheese wheel, unfortunately the photos were hard to get but the final product turned out to be a really nice and tasty pasta with lots of pecorino cheese slices. Those that enjoy pasta with more ingredients and a stronger flavour base might not enjoy it but I really liked the simplicity of the ingredients in this pasta which made it easy to eat.

To accompany the food we ordered a bottle of chinotto and an Austrian Trumer Pils beer, both were really nice and cold and helped wash down all the food that was coming out.

We were actually surprised by the price at the end of the meal since we had no control over the ordering. Considering how much we ate it all came down to only $28~ per person for the food, drinks were a little bit extra but the price was still really good for the quality of the food.

It’s not hard to imagine why the restaurant is so popular, it’s currently rated at an insanely high 96% on Urbanspoon at the time of writing! Although be warned that the restaurant gets busy by 7pm in most cases and they will not seat you without the full group present.

Buffalo Dining Club on Urbanspoon


  1. Beautiful bright coloured and fresh-looking food!

  2. can’t resist that cheese wheel! one of those restaurants where i wanna eating everything off the menu

  3. That pecorino cheese wheel!! Wow, $28 per person for so much food, that’s so good 🙂

  4. Pilllowy gnocchi and that wagyu!!! I was all sleepy but now I’m wide awake- the photos are rather eye catching haha

  5. Oh yes, I’ve heard about this famous cheese wheel! I might have to convince the fiance to go with me, it’s not too far from his workplace!

  6. yessss that gnocchi is awesome!

  7. buffalo dining club is amazing, esp that delicious pasta served in the giant pecorino wheel!

  8. Oh these cheese and that Wagyu beef bresaola!! Right up my alley 🙂 looking so delicious!!!!! Gorgeous pics! 🙂

  9. Dreaming about all those cheeses and gnocchi!!

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *